Thursday, 29 November 2018

Not of This World

Rev. Dr. Martha ter Kuile
Reign of Christ 
Bloor Street United Church
November 25, 2018
_________________________________________________________________________________

Revelation 1.4b-8

John to the seven churches that are in Asia: 

Grace to you and peace from him who is and who was and who is to come, and from the seven spirits who are before his throne, and from Jesus Christ, the faithful witness, the firstborn of the dead, and the ruler of the kings of the earth. 

To him who loves us and freed us from our sins by his blood, and made us to be a kingdom, priests serving his God and Father, to him be glory and dominion for ever and ever. Amen. Look! He is coming with the clouds; every eye will see him, even those who pierced him; and on his account all the tribes of the earth will wail. So it is to be. Amen. 

‘I am the Alpha and the Omega’, says the Lord God, who is and who was and who is to come, the Almighty. 


John 18.33-37 

Then Pilate entered the headquarters again, summoned Jesus, and asked him, ‘Are you the King of the Jews?’ Jesus answered, ‘Do you ask this on your own, or did others tell you about me?’ Pilate replied, ‘I am not a Jew, am I? Your own nation and the chief priests have handed you over to me. What have you done?’ Jesus answered, ‘My kingdom is not from this world. If my kingdom were from this world, my followers would be fighting to keep me from being handed over to the Jews. But as it is, my kingdom is not from here.’ Pilate asked him, ‘So you are a king?’ Jesus answered, ‘You say that I am a king. For this I was born, and for this I came into the world, to testify to the truth. Everyone who belongs to the truth listens to my voice.’ 
_________________________________________________________________________________

May God bless to our understanding these words from Holy Scripture. 

On the last Sunday of the church year, just before Advent starts the story all over again, we pause for a moment just to look at Jesus. Our hymns and anthems, screen images and Bible passages bring him to life in different ways. The lectionary readings give us two distinct pictures. In the first, which Randi read, we see Christ in glory, returning in the clouds to rule the earth. He is masterful, triumphant and bold. The whole world, even all the kings of the world, gather to honour him. It’s a bit of a crazy notion, an over-the-top fantasy of the world completely changed. Our Great South window captures it. Would something like that ever happen? Well, maybe not. But it’s a beautiful way of describing an era of harmony and peace, a time when time itself is overcome by a new reality. An everlasting instant in which all is well. (And it has given us some really fun hymns). It’s the kind of thing you can take seriously, without taking it literally.

But in the Gospel passage for the day, we see a very different Jesus. Here, Jesus is hardly triumphant. He has been betrayed by a follower, arrested at night, and hauled before the high priest Caiaphas. He has been blindfolded and hit and taunted by the soldiers. Now he is dragged before the Roman prefect, Pilate.

When Randi and I were in the West Bank we heard about the power of night-time arrests to generate fear and confusion. The darkness and the shock of being awakened or interrupted in a quiet time of prayer as in the Garden of Gethsemane, creates a feeling of chaos. Blindfolds and periods of solitary time allow the prisoner to imagine things that are far worse than what is likely to happen. Uncertainty breaks down the composure. Passing the prisoner from one questioner to another increases the sense of disorientation. The things we read about in the gospel story of Jesus’ arrest are simply tactics, if you want to demoralize and terrify your detainee. Happens all over the world, happens a lot in Palestine. Standing before Pilate, Jesus is in a position of extreme vulnerability.

Pilate starts out playing the role of the good cop. He seems almost a little amused by the situation, he’s not angry at Jesus. Suggests Jesus might get a fair hearing here, but really doesn’t care. Pilate’s contempt for the interests of his Jewish civil administration comes through in his mocking question, “Are you the King of the Jews?”

As the commentary Salt (www.saltproject.org) points out, “Pilate allows Jesus to be dressed and publicly presented in a purple robe and crown of thorns, a barbaric, sarcastic sneer at the “kingship” claim (John 19:1-5). In Jesus Pilate sees an opportunity to humiliate his Jewish subjects, forcing them to crucify not only this alleged king, but also the very idea of Jewish kingship in imperial Rome. The inscription [Jesus of Nazareth King of the Jews, that he will pin above Jesus on the cross] effectively says: Behold - this is what happens to your “kings!” Thus Pilate mocks and terrorizes his subjects, pushing them – by their own logic – to declare, “We have no king but the emperor!” (John 19:15).” Pilate holds them in utter contempt.

The writer Malcom Gladwell wrote about contempt in his book Blink. Citing longitudinal studies by American psychologist John Gottman, Gladwell describes long hours of video recordings made of the interactions of married couples. Looking back at the tapes much later and comparing them with the outcome of the marriages in question, Gottman noticed that an excellent, almost perfect predictor of divorce was the display of contempt. If one, or both of the partners, showed contempt for the other, the marriage was doomed. And I think this finding can be generalized. In any relationship, with friends or family, or co-workers or fellow students, or even in politics, contempt is a warning sign that irreparable harm has been done. Things don’t get better when the underlying attitude is one of disdain. Among human beings, contempt is more lethal than rage.

It also blinds you to new possibilities. As Pilate continues the interview with Jesus, we see his tendency to think in categories that are utterly conventional. He’s a colonial administrator. He can’t think past the dreary hierarchies of power. If a person seems to be outstanding in some way, he must want to be a king. Because what else would anyone want to be? Surely anyone who had the chance would want to boss everyone else around. And that is one of the reasons you have to keep strict control of them. You have to keep them down. If you give them an inch, they’ll take a mile. Pilate is completely locked into this narrow view of humanity. Between his scorn for those he considers his inferiors and the clichés of his boring little establishment world, he cannot see who is standing in front of him.

Jesus doesn’t argue with this man who holds the power of life and death over him. But he changes the conversation. He deflects the question about being a king, twice. Begins an explanation – my kingdom is not of this world… Hah, so you are a king, says Pilate. Again, Jesus defers. But then he clarifies, puts it right on the table. This is what I was born for: to testify to the truth. Born to it, as a king is born to it, a destiny from birth. Not to exert dominion over others, or to have them bow down to me. Much simpler than conquering foreign lands or running an empire. Christ’s entire claim is to testify to the truth. To see it, to be a witness to what is true in the world. To cut through all the nonsense and pretension of religious traditions and political institutions, to look at hierarchies and chains of command and see them for the fragile human constructions they are. To be entirely unimpressed by the posturing of tyrants or the bluster of bullies. Instead he is here to see the truth, and to speak about it. Jesus tells Pilate that he was born to tell the truth of God’s love for the world, the truth of compassion, the truth of hope. Jesus’ testimony to the truth has taken him into the homes of the rich and to the bedside of the dying. He has touched the blind and the lame with healing hands, and preached to the hungry multitudes from a mountainside. This testimony will now take him to his death.

Moreover, he says, everyone who belongs to the truth can hear my voice. No one is excluded. No special formulas or esoteric knowledge. Just a heart for listening. And willingness to know the truth. 

When we celebrate the reign of Christ on this final Sunday of the Christian calendar, it is this king we recall. A king whose dominion is the truth: a piercing glimpse of reality that can come as if descending in the clouds at any time and in any place. In the words of Revelation, this is Alpha and Omega, the beginning and the end. As his followers we too are called to a simple task: to be witnesses to the truth. Not the rulers, but the truthtellers. Whether it is climate change, or violence against women, or Israel-Palestine or something small and personal, our call is to seek the truth and say it. For wherever the truth is told, there is the reign of Christ. And for this we give God thanks. Amen.

Friday, 16 November 2018

Remembering, Recognizing, Hoping

Rev. Linda Butler
Remembrance Day 
Bloor Street United Church
November 11, 2018
_________________________________________________________________________________

Micah 4.1-4 

In days to come 
 the mountain of the LORD’s house 
shall be established as the highest of the mountains, 
 and shall be raised up above the hills. 
Peoples shall stream to it, 
 and many nations shall come and say: 
‘Come, let us go up to the mountain of the LORD, 
 to the house of the God of Jacob; 
that he may teach us his ways 
 and that we may walk in his paths.’ 
For out of Zion shall go forth instruction, 
 and the word of the LORD from Jerusalem. 
 He shall judge between many peoples, 
 and shall arbitrate between strong nations far away; 
they shall beat their swords into ploughshares, 
 and their spears into pruning-hooks; 
nation shall not lift up sword against nation, 
 neither shall they learn war any more; 
 but they shall all sit under their own vines and under their own fig trees, 
 and no one shall make them afraid; 
 for the mouth of the LORD of hosts has spoken. 


Matthew 5.9, 43-48 

‘Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God. 

‘You have heard that it was said, “You shall love your neighbour and hate your enemy.” But I say to you, Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you, so that you may be children of your Father in heaven; for he makes his sun rise on the evil and on the good, and sends rain on the righteous and on the unrighteous. For if you love those who love you, what reward do you have? Do not even the tax-collectors do the same? And if you greet only your brothers and sisters, what more are you doing than others? Do not even the Gentiles do the same? Be perfect, therefore, as your heavenly Father is perfect. 
_________________________________________________________________________________

I was meeting with my Conference Personnel Officer when I made my momentous announcement. After eight years serving in pastoral charges, I was now certain that I was called to rural ministry. In all probability that would be solo, but I might consider entering into team with a long time, trusted friend. That evening, my phone rang. It was a member of the Search Committee from Bloor Street. Several months later, pen in hand, I was signing a call form agreeing to be at Bloor Street, in team with Warren McDougall whom I had just met the day before. I was doing what I had promised myself I never would, and it was one of the best decisions in my life. Twenty-five years later, we are still working together as consultants with Toronto United Church Council.

Over those years, Warren has offered me many pearls of wisdom, one of which I want to share with you today. Speaking about funerals, he said: we need to do three things – remember the past, celebrating the life lived; recognize the present, grieving the loss; look to the future, embracing the hope. It seems to me this is also wise advice for a Remembrance Day service.

We remember the past. It was one hundred years ago today that an armistice was declared and the roar of the guns was stilled. World War I was finally over. Even my Mom, who is a fairly lively 102, cannot claim to have memories from that day, let alone any of us gathered here this morning. But some may have looked through family albums and seen fading black and white photos of earnest young men in uniform – grandfathers, great uncles – who died in the mud, the chaos, the stench, and the horror of the trenches or succumbed to the flu in overcrowded training camps. Some of us may have met one of the veterans who returned to their farms and homes, changed by their experience. Some of these men struggled with the after effects of being gassed or having a limb amputated. Some, apparently sound of body, never spoke of what they had been through, not wanting loved ones to share their nightmares. Others told their stories, hoping to ensure that this would indeed be the war to end all wars.

It has been over seventy years since World War II came to a close. The ranks of veterans are thinning, but thanks to documentary films and movies, history books and novels, even those of us who did not live through that war can learn about the battles and the Holocaust, the prisoner of war camps and the forced removal and internment of Japanese Canadians, the London blitz and the dropping of the first nuclear bomb on Hiroshima. We may cross paths with people like Wilhelm whose father was a minister in the German Confessing Church which, at great cost, opposed Hitler, and who can remember sitting on Dietrich Bonhoeffer's knee. Or Phyllis who was a bomb girl making munitions in Toronto, part of the wave of women entering the workforce, forever altering society's understanding of the role of women, or the Russian General who delighted in telling the tale of swimming across a German river with a bottle of vodka to share with the American troops on the other side.

In my own childhood, it was the Korean conflict. As a young adult, I had hopes that the days were over when Canadians would be fighting in wars: our efforts would be confined to United Nations peace keeping missions like the one now in Mali where 250 Canadians are serving. That was not to be. As if the procession of coffins along the 401 and Don Valley Parkway was not enough to bring that home, my favourite dog walking park in Richmond Hill is named Matthew Dinning after a young Air Force officer who lost his life in Afghanistan. Last year when I attended the Remembrance Day service at my local Anglican Church, his parents were in the congregation.

We remember the past – honouring the sacrifices of those who have gone before us, and grieving the loss of so many lives. We recognize the present reality. At this moment, Canada may not be at war. Unlike in previous ages, the world may not be racked by conventional conflicts between nation states. But and it is a big but, our world is still a very violent place. More and more wars are essentially internal conflicts, which tend to last even longer. Just think of Afghanistan – how many years have the people in that country been suffering? or Syria where the civil war is in its eighth year, the Central African Republic, or the Congo, Somalia or Sudan. The time is long past when armies engaged in set actions far from civilian populations. Now, the destruction is extreme: cities reduced to rubble; villages burned to the ground. Now, civilians are unsure which way to flee as bombs fall from the skies and some like the Yazidis are left with nowhere to go. As UNICEF reports: "armed conflict [today] kills and maims more children than soldiers." Children who do survive the bombs and air strikes are not home free. In places like Yemen, they are at risk from cholera and famine. At the very least, children and youth face the loss of opportunities for schooling and recreation. Our entire planet is the poorer when children have no chance to reach their full potential.

We recognize the present reality with ears open to hear the cries of distress and hearts open to the pain and fear of children, women, men. But we do not stop there. We turn our eyes to the future. War may be something in which human beings have been engaged for millennia, but that does not mean we must accept it as inevitable. The prophet Micah, like us, lived in a world in which there was little of peace, little of harmony among people. His own homeland of Judah had been caught in the struggle between the great powers and crushed by a mighty invading army. Yet this very real, very painful experience did not obliterate his hope for a better future. He sings: "they shall beat their swords into ploughshares and their spears into pruning hooks" – military equipment turned into agricultural tools; weapons that inflicted death and destruction now bringing life and sustenance. I always loved this verse: every year on Remembrance Sunday, I have worn my poppy in memory of our veterans, but also my button with these words from Micah to proclaim my hope that things can be different.

This year when I was praying this scripture, it was another verse that held my attention: "they shall all sit under their own vines and under their own fig trees." What a bold vision, especially in our world today where 65 million people are refugees. Like the Rohingya who had to flee from Mynamar; the Syrians who have been displaced; the Central Americans in the caravans who are seeking to escape violence and poverty. In Micah's vision, not only are people at home in their very own place, but they also have a secure food source. Famine is not able to stalk them – no children with distended bellies and stick like legs and arms. Food shortages are not going to make hard lives even more difficult. 

"They shall all sit under their own vines and under their own fig trees, and no one shall make them afraid." Wouldn't that be awesome? For the child in Yemen who knows that even riding on a school bus is not safe. For the woman on her own in a refugee camp where fetching firewood or water can put her in danger of sexual assault. For the man whose life may be taken because he is deemed to belong to the wrong ethnic group or a heretical religion or a dangerous political movement.

"They shall all sit under their own vines and under their own fig trees and no one shall make them afraid." I know this does not reflect our present reality. It is a dream. But you and I are meant to be "dreamers of the dream". I first heard that phrase on the lips of Herbert O'Driscoll, an Anglican priest, who was teaching a preaching course. On a dismal, grey day, he looked around the circle of weary, dispirited ministers and declared: "you are dreamers of the dream. You are proclaimers of the dawn when it is midnight." Heads were raised. Eyes lit up. That is indeed who we are, not just those of us who have had hands laid on, but each and every person of faith. We are invited to dream the dream – God's dream of justice and peace. We are called to declare: the world can be different. Hatred and divisions, strikes and counter-strikes, acts of violence and revenge are not inevitable.

As we dream this dream, we may become more open to hearing, really hearing, teachings that challenge not only our assumptions about ourselves, our neighbours, and our enemies, but also our accepted approaches to dealing with one another. Teachings like those of Jesus: "love your enemies". As Karen Armstrong points out in her book, Twelve Steps to a Compassionate Life, "Jesus is preaching an openhanded, openhearted attitude designed ... to disarm the enemy. Such love expects no personal recompense." This openhanded, openhearted attitude is reflected in the life of Jesus who eats with Pharisees and sinners; talks with a Samaritan woman by a well and touches a leper; and who on the cross forgives his executioners. We may be thinking that is all very inspiring, but "Love your enemies" still sounds like an impossibility for ordinary women and men like us.

Along comes Karen Armstrong. I read Twelve Steps to a Compassionate Life one summer. I was impressed and organized a book study group at Richmond Hill United Church. We ended up going through it, not once, but twice, over the course of two years. We came to realize that Armstrong is absolutely right: there are no quick fixes; no easy answers. But small steps are possible. We can learn to be more compassionate. We can try to expand the circle of our concern and care, wishing for the well-being and happiness of ourselves, our loved ones, our enemies.

While remembering the past, and recognizing the present, we can be dreamers of God's dream of a world of justice and peace. We can live into Micah's vision of everyone sitting under their own vine and fig tree and no one making them afraid. Thanks be to God. Amen.