Friday, 4 May 2018

The Trouble with Love

Rev. Dr. Martha ter Kuile
Fifth Sunday of Eastertide 
Bloor Street United Church
April 29, 2018
_________________________________________________________________________________

Psalm 36 

To the leader. Of David, the servant of the LORD. 
Transgression speaks to the wicked 
 deep in their hearts; 
there is no fear of God 
 before their eyes. 
 For they flatter themselves in their own eyes 
 that their iniquity cannot be found out and hated. 
The words of their mouths are mischief and deceit; 
 they have ceased to act wisely and do good. 
 They plot mischief while on their beds; 
 they are set on a way that is not good; 
 they do not reject evil. 

 Your steadfast love, O LORD, extends to the heavens, 
 your faithfulness to the clouds. 
 Your righteousness is like the mighty mountains, 
 your judgements are like the great deep; 
 you save humans and animals alike, O LORD. 

How precious is your steadfast love, O God! 
 All people may take refuge in the shadow of your wings. 
 They feast on the abundance of your house, 
 and you give them drink from the river of your delights. 
 For with you is the fountain of life; 
 in your light we see light. 

O continue your steadfast love to those who know you, 
 and your salvation to the upright of heart! 
 Do not let the foot of the arrogant tread on me, 
 or the hand of the wicked drive me away. 
 There the evildoers lie prostrate; 
 they are thrust down, unable to rise. 


1 John 4.7-8, 16-21 

Beloved, let us love one another, because love is from God; everyone who loves is born of God and knows God. Whoever does not love does not know God, for God is love. So we have known and believe the love that God has for us. 

God is love, and those who abide in love abide in God, and God abides in them. Love has been perfected among us in this: that we may have boldness on the day of judgement, because as he is, so are we in this world. There is no fear in love, but perfect love casts out fear; for fear has to do with punishment, and whoever fears has not reached perfection in love. We love because he first loved us. Those who say, ‘I love God’, and hate their brothers or sisters, are liars; for those who do not love a brother or sister whom they have seen, cannot love God whom they have not seen. The commandment we have from him is this: those who love God must love their brothers and sisters also. 


John 15.1-8 

I am the true vine, and my Father is the vine-grower. He removes every branch in me that bears no fruit. Every branch that bears fruit he prunes to make it bear more fruit. You have already been cleansed by the word that I have spoken to you. Abide in me as I abide in you. Just as the branch cannot bear fruit by itself unless it abides in the vine, neither can you unless you abide in me. I am the vine, you are the branches. Those who abide in me and I in them bear much fruit, because apart from me you can do nothing. Whoever does not abide in me is thrown away like a branch and withers; such branches are gathered, thrown into the fire, and burned. If you abide in me, and my words abide in you, ask for whatever you wish, and it will be done for you. My Father is glorified by this, that you bear much fruit and become my disciples. 

_________________________________________________________________________________


May God bless to our understanding these words from Holy Scripture. 

Well, I admit that it snowed this morning, but…

At last, I think we can agree that spring is here. After such a hard, halting, ridiculous, discouraging start, we can sing our Easter-y hymns without irony. The green blade is rising, as the grass begins to change from the colour of old hay to the beloved green of new life. Brave little crocuses no longer need to push through crusts of snow. If you look at a group of trees together, in a ravine or along the parkway, or out in the country, they give off a cloudy shimmer of pink – the twigs have fattened with sap, and the redness of the very first buds promises millions of leaves about to pop. By next week the shimmer will be green. On city streets, the dust of old winter is washed away in the spring rain, and it seems that the earth itself is singing hallelujah.

The scripture readings have a spring feel to them today too. In the passage from the Gospel of John that Allison read, Jesus refers to himself as a vine. If anyone has ever had a grapevine you’ll know that when the rootstock is strong, the branches grow and flourish almost miraculously in the spring. Left to their own devices, they will just take over whatever is near enough to serve as a trellis. At our farm in Ashton we had a garden swing that I moved near a wild grape, because I thought it would be so charming and fragrant to swing surrounded by the wild grape blossoms. Forget it, the swing was completely overgrown in one season! As I found out and as Jesus indicates, a gardener has to prune. And when you prune you see clearly that the moment a branch is cut off, it begins to wilt and die. It can’t live at all without being connected. The spring metaphor of a surging vine tells us as much about the power of connection as it does about the sheer abundance of the harvest. Abide in me, Jesus says. Be connected.

And of course, it isn’t just plants that need to be connected to thrive. On a baptism Sunday we celebrate the grace of God that flows over and around us like baptismal waters, the wonder of creation in the person of a baby – but we also celebrate the power of connection, and the deep ties between a child and his family, a family and their community, a community and a whole company of faith. As we have clearly seen this morning, Grayden is connected to his parents Genina and Maria, [and to his remarkable family] and also to all of us, and beyond this congregation to the whole worldwide Christian church. It will be the strength of those connections that make it possible for the parents to fulfill the baptismal promises made today. Grayden’s growth and wellbeing over the years, like the wellbeing of every one of us, will be a function of the depth of his attachments to the various communities in which he lives his life. Human beings do need to abide in one another in order to flourish.

This could hardly have been more clear this week, as people in Toronto and around the world responded with dismay and grief to the violence of a meaningless attack on people strolling down the sidewalk in the sunshine of a lovely day. The dead and injured weren’t his enemies, just his victims. It seems he wasn’t fighting for a cause, but impelled by his own demons. The victims were random, not chosen by gender or race, or age, or status. A downtown chef, a tennis lover, a school board lunchroom employee, a great-grandmother, a college student, visitors from Jordan and Korea. Poignantly, as we learn more about them, we see that as a group they were like a snapshot of the new Canada, the diverse and inclusive society that we live in now. The community that we want to learn to be.

We don’t know much about the van driver. It seems that mental illness had made him isolated, had disconnected him from family and schoolmates and fellow army recruits and co-workers. It seems that he was not able to receive the human connections that were offered.

It is those human connections that have been so remarkable in the news reports this week. Interviews with friends and relatives, stories of relationships and conversations – the memories shared have moved us all. As sometimes happens in a crisis, we have seen not only the worst but also the best in people. The compassion of a young woman who sat on the sidewalk with a stranger to be with him as he died, the self-discipline of a police officer who refused to be goaded into violence, the humanity and calm in the voices of our political leaders, the outpouring of care as people have reached out to a child orphaned by the attack, and to spread spring flowers at the site of the tragedy. It is not too much to say that we have been surrounded by love. Tabitha Southey wrote, it feels as if this is a place on high alert for kindness.

And of course, we also know that for those who were close to the ten who have died, and for those who are facing a long recovery from injury and trauma, this is only the beginning of a hard journey of grief. For all of us, as individuals and as a society, the effort to accept, to forgive, to keep on living will demand even more care and compassion, more love. And this kind of love is difficult.

But that is the trouble with love. It IS difficult. From the most intimate to the most grandiose philosophical love, the trouble with love is that when you most need it, it may be hard to find. We are all in love with Grayden this morning, but when he wakes for the fourth time in the middle of the night Genina and Maria still have to find it in themselves to hold him gently, and figure out what’s wrong. And, as we know, in many ways parenting doesn’t get easier as the child grows! More love needed.

In our marriages and families and communities too, the impulses of closeness and good feeling that we have at special, happy times have to be supplemented by patience and perseverance and toleration. We have to navigate disagreements and dysfunctionalities in all our relationships. Partners and families don’t hold on to each other because it is always such a pleasure. People don’t stick with a congregation because it is so much fun to go to budget meetings, or so easy to befriend a needy stranger. The jobs we do as volunteers or employees in our neighbourhood, or our city, or our country are often more demanding than rewarding. The trouble with love is that it inevitably leads you into situations where it is almost impossible to love, times when you reach down inside yourself, and come up empty.

And that is just the simple reality – we don’t love as we intend to, and actually we can’t love as we should. You can’t do it by will alone. That is the human condition. The thing is, love doesn’t come from within us. As the writer of the letters of John said in our passage today, it comes from God. God is love, he says. And those who know love, know God. When we find we cannot love, it is because we have lost the connection to that everlasting source. Jesus talks about it as a connection to the true vine. When he says Abide in me, Jesus invites us to allow God’s steadfast love to flow into us, to replenish and renew. When we are able to receive the flow of energy and goodness that we have known in Jesus, we will be able to love in our turn. And for this we give God thanks. 

Let us pray:  Creator, you are the source of all love. Abide in us, flow through us, let us be the bearers of your love for the world. Amen.

Only Goodness and Mercy?

Rabbi Elyse Goldstein, City Shul
Fourth Sunday of Easter – Celebrating Earth Day 
Bloor Street United Church
 April 22, 2018
_________________________________________________________________________________

Psalm 23 

The LORD is my shepherd, I shall not want. 
 He makes me lie down in green pastures; 
he leads me beside still waters; he restores my soul. 
He leads me in right paths for his name’s sake. 

 Even though I walk through the darkest valley, 
 I fear no evil; 
for you are with me; 
 your rod and your staff— they comfort me. 

 You prepare a table before me 
 in the presence of my enemies; 
you anoint my head with oil; 
 my cup overflows. 

 Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me 
 all the days of my life, 
and I shall dwell in the house of the LORD 
 my whole life long. 
_________________________________________________________________________________

Thank you all so much for inviting me, and for the partnership which keeps growing between our two congregations. I am appreciating my now common lunches with Martha, and the Shabbat dinner we did together. And when our 10 commandments tapestry was accidentally defaced, how, in so much love, this church jumped to attention and did everything possible to help us.

So… how does my congregation feel about the move so far?

On the one hand, we are getting used to not facing east, which is traditionally important to us in our prayers. On the other hand we continually feel the extraordinary blessing to live in the 21st century where Jews and Christians can comfortably exchange ideas, and much more than that, we feel so grateful because we now have Christian allies and friends who speak up and out with us and for us, because they have a deep relationship with us as Jews, as a synagogue—not despite who we are but because of who we are—and I trust that you at Bloor Street United Church will help us unmask the lie of what feels like social acceptance of quiet, and sometimes not so quiet, anti-Semitism. You folks at Bloor Street United may not always understand us or our Jewish customs or the myriad laws and rules and superstitions and sensitivities we seem to change at a moment’s notice or invent as we go along; but your patience and friendship, and often going out of your way and bending backwards to accommodate us, has been deeply felt and appreciated by us.

I personally will never forget the extraordinary welcome we received here as we paraded our Torah scrolls in, and we, as much as you, got to witness a piece of history in our lifetimes. We were received not just with open arms, but with open hearts. I looked up that morning and saw our member George, child of Holocaust survivors from Hungary, weeping. I looked at our new ark, an antique armoire donated by good Catholic Mr. Johnston, in memory of his mother, lovingly refurbished by Mr. Lee, an Asian woodcrafter, whose work was generously paid for by Myra and Adrienne, a Jewish lesbian couple, and decorated by my husband Baruch, the son of ardent Zionists who made illegal aliyah in 1947. All around me were Christians saying mazel tov, and our City Shul kids were waving Canadian flags, and I thought: this is exactly how the world is supposed to be.

And that feeling of how the world is “supposed to be” is the challenge of Psalm 23 read in your lectionary today. It’s such a beautifully comforting image of God as our shepherd, gently guiding us through dark valleys and still waters and restoring our souls. And the promise at the end: “surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life…” but wait a minute. Maybe King David had the kind of faith, after a lifetime of getting all the women he wanted and securing his own son on the throne, that surely goodness and mercy would follow him all the days of his life. But I myself am not so sure.

The original Hebrew of these lines is vitally important in understanding what the Psalmist was trying to tell us.

That word, “surely” in Hebrew is “ach.” That word “ach” appears 22 times in the Hebrew Bible, and half those times it can be translated as “only”. Wow—only goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life. Well, I don’t know about your lives but I have not had ONLY goodness and mercy in mine, and you’d think I have a special connection, and if anyone deserves ONLY goodness and mercy it would be clergy like me and Martha. But, I’ve had a lot of other things follow me through my life; just like all of you: troubles and trials and challenges and bad luck and things gone wrong and loss and heartache.

So, what else can this ach mean? The other half of the Biblical references with the word ach mean “although, yet, despite.” The Talmud, in Mashechet Berachot, says that when the Torah uses the word ach, instead of the more common word rak, it intends to teach limitation. In other words, despite walking through the valley of the shadows, we still hold out hope that goodness and mercy will be behind us, moving us forward, pursuing us a little, giving us light.

Now, if you take note of the six few lines in the Psalm, you will see that the first three lines of the Psalm are in the third person: The Lord is my shepherd… God leads in straight paths… for the sake of His name.

But then, in verse four we walk through the valley of the shadow of death. And suddenly, the Psalm switches and uses the second person, “I will fear no evil for You are with me, Your rod and Your staff, they comfort me.” When we walk through the valley of the shadows, we have two choices—to reach out and hope that faith and God and community will catch us; or to turn away from community and God, to blame God for not giving us ONLY goodness and mercy, and to let the darkness be our definitional pivotal point away from faith.

I will tell you a painful and personal story which some of you heard if you came to see my show The Clergy Project.

In 1992 my only sibling, my then 40 year-old sister, died suddenly and totally unexpectedly. My world was turned upside down and inside out, and I ran home to New York with my husband, leaving a six month-old and a two year old with my best friends here in Toronto. At the memorial week, after the funeral when we have visitations, a woman from my parents’ synagogue came up to me, and very pointedly said, “I bet you don’t believe in God anymore now, do you?” She was literally exuding her own anger at God, her own sorrow and disappointment in her life, her own anxieties — but she wanted me, in my sorrow, to validate them. I turned to her and answered, “Now, I believe more than ever.” And I meant it sincerely. I let God hold my hand through that valley; I asked my community to be my rod and staff, and like Rabbi Harold Kushner who wrote When Bad Things Happen to Good People, I allowed God to come into my sorrow and comfort me there.

And then, the Psalm tells me what to do: v’shavti b’veit Hashem, translated as “I will dwell in the house of the Lord” but the root of the word to dwell—v’shavti—really means “I will return to the house of the Lord.” After I fully understand that not only goodness and mercy will follow me, then I’m ready, then I’m mature enough, then I can return to the house of the Lord to be a full participant in a religious community.

When I know that only goodness and mercy will not follow me all the days of my life, I have two choices—to push God out of that reality in disappointment and anger that I’m not getting all the goodness and mercy I was promised; or to return—v’shavti—to the house of God—in my case, the synagogue, and in yours, the church. God is inviting me into a permanent relationship and I will be mature enough for that relationship only after I’ve walked a little through the valleys, and only after I’ve stopped expecting that my life will be only goodness and mercy.

So, let’s translate and live by Psalm 23 as: Oh, may goodness and mercy please follow me all the days of my life, but, should they not, I will return to God’s abode anyway, to search for the way to love in fullness, in spite of, and in acknowledgement of the valleys we walk through just by being alive.

So, our two houses of God combined here have that goal in common: that we strive to be places of comfort in a discomforting world; that we strive to be lush green pastures (and especially today in light of Earth day, that we be very green pastures!) where our souls can feel refreshed by the still waters; that we strive to acknowledge that our cups are overflowing with the blessing of our new partnership. May we return each week or each holiday or each event to this shared house with a renewed maturity that invites God to bless our endeavours, and to walk with us. Amen.