Rachel Clark – Transgender Activist
Guest Preacher
Third Sunday after Pentecost – Celebrating 22 Years as an Affirming Congregation
Bloor Street United Church
June 25, 2017
_________________________________________________________________________________
Jeremiah 22.13-17
Woe to him who builds his house by unrighteousness,
and his upper rooms by injustice;
who makes his neighbours work for nothing,
and does not give them their wages;
who says, ‘I will build myself a spacious house
with large upper rooms’,
and who cuts out windows for it,
panelling it with cedar,
and painting it with vermilion.
Are you a king
because you compete in cedar?
Did not your father eat and drink
and do justice and righteousness?
Then it was well with him.
He judged the cause of the poor and needy;
then it was well.
Is not this to know me?
says the LORD.
But your eyes and heart
are only on your dishonest gain,
for shedding innocent blood,
and for practising oppression and violence.
_________________________________________________________________________________
Not far from here, last year, I was in a meeting where I was a volunteer for the board of directors for Pride Toronto. The room was filled with marginalized people of various races, backgrounds, gender identities and sexual orientations. The community was angry that action wasn't being taken on some things, and were vocally screaming at me and other board members. As the room was more heated, more volatile, I remember feeling this great sickness in the pit of my stomach, because I didn't want to listen and I didn't want to be there. When someone looked over at me and yelled 'You're a Racist!", suddenly, I disengaged, threw up my hands and said "I can't win!" The pit in my stomach had become a full on dry heave of stress, angst, and defeat. I failed, and carried the 'racist' moniker on my chest like Hester Prynne and the Scarlet Letter A. "I'm a racist."
And when I first came out as Trans, I wrote something on my Facebook to which a fellow member of the community called me out on and she said I suffered from 'Internalized Transphobia". How can I be scared of Trans people when I am one? And furthermore, how can we just throw out accusatory terms like that with no basis in fact? I love Trans people because I am one, I thought, and in hearing that I scoffed at this notion, to which she deleted me from Facebook, and I haven't heard from her since. "I'm a Transphobe."
Then there were all the times that I used the word "gay" as a slur (such as 'that's so gay'), and once being called out on that by a gay gentleman, I retorted "How can I be a homophobe when I am a lesbian?" It is a paradox, isn't it? "I'm a homophobe."
Friday I had a conversation with my colleague about what allyship means, who in turn said that just because he's a white male, doesn't mean he's personally responsible for all that ails the world. And began to list of his wide and varied accomplishments of anti-racism, queer positive actions in his life. This was interesting to me because I never accused him of anything and just elicited his thoughts. It was quite a strange reaction to me considering that I just wanted to talk about allyship. Why so defensive?
Perhaps it's fatigue of being in a world where one who is atop the privilege pyramid never has to know what marginalization feels like, and being called out for not knowing what it feels like. He probably won't ever know what it feels like to be called a slur in the streets, be the victim of random violence, be denied a job or promotion for being a person of colour, or being gay or Trans. He won't have to be marginalized. Allyship then comes with ease and without discomfort because at the end of the day, he won't be the direct recipient of it. But I will.
I asked him then to consider how I might feel being a Transgender person, when I don't get the opportunity to say that I have done enough. My allyship with other marginalized communities means being in communion with them, more than just acts of allyship. It means living in this world with them as they live. When I am saying that just being a 'friend' isn't enough, and being a friend is not an indication of true allyship, then we have created space to have a conversation.
My friend Dave is a large bodybuilder type, who identifies as a 'bear' – a gay man who presents rugged masculinity. One of the things that endears me about Dave is that there was a similar conversation between him and I, and he told me a story. One day while at the Gym, he was taking the subway home when there was a young trans woman on the car with him. You may not know this, but the most likely place that Trans people are accosted is in the subway, and so it's a pretty frightening space. And the young trans person on the train, she was doing what trans people do on the subway, minding her own business.
There were four young men though on the train that night and in their car, and they came over to her and started harassing her. Harassing language directed toward her which she ignored. What else can one do when you are being accosted and you aren't in a position of power? Dave moved closer to her and when the subway came to a stop, he got out with her and so did the young men. Dave purposefully placed himself between her and them and as they were going up the escalator the young men were shouting 'Wait until we get outside" and continued their epithets. Dave turned around and said "You are going to leave my sister alone now …or else".
The young boys stopped, and they left. The young Trans woman turned and hugged him. Dave told me that it was one of the scariest moments of his life, but it was the right thing for him to do. I asked him what he would have done if they attacked him, and he said he had no idea what he would have done. I thought what he did was heroic. He saved her life, and used his power to stop a vulnerable person from being abused.
Jesus went to the Mount of Olives and while he was there, some of the Pharisees brought a woman to him and told Jesus that she was to be stoned for committing adultery. Stoning back then, or throwing stones at someone until they died, was a common form of execution in the Ancient Near East. But Jesus believed that we were all equal in sin, and when the Pharisees had encircled the woman and prepared to cast their stones at her, Jesus said "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone", the Pharisees realizing they were no better, or at least not in a place to dispense justice, dissipated and left the woman alive.
What Jesus already knew was that this was another thing that was angering those who were going to eventually crucify him, but he defended her anyway. He could have let the punishment of the time just play out as it had little to do with him. By stepping in, they could have revolted and attacked him instead. Interfering in an execution was a crime, after all. Jesus took a risk to protect a vulnerable person and did it because he did what was the right thing to do, no matter how uncomfortable it was for him then.
The Bible is rich in social justice narratives, about those who are in a position of power protecting those who couldn't protect themselves, or standing up in the face of adversity to stand up for what is right and good and wholesome to make our society a better place. They knew the one lesson that we all need to learn, that being an ally to marginalized people is an ongoing and forever process. It's not something they just did one time, it wasn't a single act, it was an ongoing and uncomfortable process that made for real results, and what we are called as people of Christianity to do.
What does Christian allyship look like for us today? First is knowing that being an ally is not a noun, and it's identity, but it is something that we do. Allyship is an action that we take to say that we are going to live in communion with marginalized people. The first thing that allies need to do is to listen, and not to just one person, but to many diverse voices in a community. For example, I don't speak for all Trans people, but much can be gleaned by listening to me and other trans people about where marginalization lies. Allyship is a forever commitment. I t's something that you can't just stop and start when it's convenient. It means that acting on allyship is a part of your DNA. It means constantly reading and learning. It means constantly listening and talking only where it's appropriate.
"Ugh, I just don't have the energy to respond to my cousin who is being a homophobe again on Facebook", for example. But oppressed people don't have the opportunity to opt-out of homophobia, transphobia, racism, classism, ableism or xenophobia. It is a privilege to be able to opt-out of defending the oppressed, and performing the work of allyship means that we can't opt-out either.
And allies focus on those who share their identity. Because I am a person who benefits from white privilege every day for example, it's not appropriate for me to engage people of color about what is, and what is not racist. But what I can do is engage with those who share my identity. Talking to other white people about how we are contributing to racist institutions and how we have a responsibility to dismantle that, for example, is an act of allyship.
Yes, I was called a racist, a homophobe, and a transphobe, and the best thing that I could do was to recognize that I was contributing to oppressive systems, apologize and learn more so that I can do better. It wasn't something that happened overnight for me. But I did what allies should do, I learned and committed to doing better.
We don't like being called names, but we also need to understand what words like racism, transphobia, and xenophobia mean and understand that each and every one of us is a contributor to systems of oppression, and because we are complicit in those, intentionally and unintentionally, we are committing acts of racism, homophobia, ableism, and so forth.
You have embarked here on a 22-year journey of affirming that all people have a place at God's table here in this Church. Being affirming is more than a process though. It's about making this space a place for difficult conversations about how we can learn and do better. And so let me tell you how I think you can do better as a Christian community for Transgender people during this Pride Sunday.
Right now, Christianity all over the world has been used as a tool to make laws to try to erase the existence of Transgender people, and it's happening here in Canada. One only has to look toward the debates in the Canadian Senate and House of Commons on the rights of Transgender people to understand how much it is shockingly used. That gender is God-defined, binary, and unchangeable flies in the face of an all-encompassing God who transcends Gender. If we are created in the image of God, then simply put God is Transgender, God is pansexual, God is dis/abled, God is a person of colour, God is female, and God is you. And denying that, is denying the very crux of every major religious belief. And when we do work to marginalize people, we are in fact marginalizing God.
We must do better as a Church to reclaim Christianity as a religion of social justice, inclusion, and keeping with biblical tradition if we want to consider ourselves allies and affirming. We must ensure that we are vocal and open about who Christians are as a people, rather than letting the narrative be taken away by our politicians and harmful Christian fundamentalism. If we are not vocal about the true meaning of an inclusion based Christ like Christianity, then we are not doing the work of allies to LGBT people. And we are not protecting vulnerable people.
So, I challenge you today, to reenergize your fight as the oldest Affirming congregation in the United Church of Canada to explore new opportunities to be allies, and do justice. To create a much bigger space for marginalized people and live in communion with them, not just be their neighbours. Amen.
No comments:
Post a Comment