Friday, 22 December 2017

Never Again

George Bartlett and Marianna Harris
Guest Preachers
Second Sunday of Advent 
Bloor Street United Church
December 10, 2017
_________________________________________________________________________________

George: 

One of the few stories which all four gospels tell is the story of John the Baptist preparing the way for Jesus. Every Advent, John plays a key role as we wait.

Mark links John to the prophet Isaiah, a sacred figure of the Jewish past.

And all four gospels place John in the wilderness – the place where God accompanied the people, even as they wandered and struggled and questioned. John calls us to repentance. So, every year we need to remind ourselves what this word means in a biblical sense. Repentance signifies turning around – changing one’s mind, one’s way of thinking.
_________________________________________________________________________________

Let us hear Mark’s introduction to the good news from Mark 1 verses 1-8:

The Proclamation of John the Baptist 

1 The beginning of the good news of Jesus Christ, the Son of God. 

2 As it is written in the prophet Isaiah, 
‘See, I am sending my messenger ahead of you, 
 who will prepare your way; 
 3 the voice of one crying out in the wilderness: 
 “Prepare the way of the Lord, 
 make his paths straight” ’, 

4 John the baptizer appeared in the wilderness, proclaiming a baptism of repentance for the forgiveness of sins. 5 And people from the whole Judean countryside and all the people of Jerusalem were going out to him, and were baptized by him in the river Jordan, confessing their sins. 6 Now John was clothed with camel’s hair, with a leather belt around his waist, and he ate locusts and wild honey. 7 He proclaimed, ‘The one who is more powerful than I is coming after me; I am not worthy to stoop down and untie the thong of his sandals. 8I have baptized you with water; but he will baptize you with the Holy Spirit.’ 
_________________________________________________________________________________

I am pleased to speak with you today, and equally pleased that my partner Marianna is willing to share part of the message.

On this Advent Sunday, when we focus on peace, let us do it in the spirit of theologian Frederick Buechner who declares that “Peace means not the absence of struggle but the presence of love.” 

Personally, I would also add that there cannot be peace without justice.

“Never again”. Perhaps you have heard that phrase.

After the revelation of the massive deaths in the concentration camps, the world was horrified. It is estimated that 11 million people died. Jehovah’s Witnesses, disabled people, Roma and homosexuals made up nearly half of those that died. Six million of the deaths were Jewish people. The killings began in 1933 and ended in 1945. 

‘Never again’ is a refrain which was born out of the Nazi brutality. And the world reaction to this horror was more than platitudes or the wringing of hands. The United Nations was formed to find an alternative to war.

Sixty-nine years ago today the Universal Declaration of Human Rights was adopted as a noble effort to prevent the atrocities perpetrated by Nazi Germany.

Eight months later the Fourth Geneva Convention was adopted. Its purpose was to protect civilians in light of what had happened during the Second World War.

Am I just being a boring lawyer as I explain this to you? Perhaps. But this background is essential to the stories I am going to tell you from the three months that I served as an ecumenical accompanier in Palestine. Some of the stories are part of this sermon; many more will be shared with refreshments in McClure Hall after the service.

The framework for telling these stories is international law – ways in which the international community aspires to live together in peace based on justice. And it is international law which is being broken, ignored daily by the government of Israel.

From February to April I lived in Palestine serving as an ecumenical accompanier – on behalf of the United Church of Canada and under the auspices of the World Council of Churches. Contributions to the Mission and Service Fund of the United Church paid the expenses to get me there. I was part of a team of five. (A picture is shown of the Team in the central square of Tulkarm, the City in which they lived.) However, most of our time was spent visiting other communities in the northwest part of the occupied West Bank.

And ‘Occupied’ is the most important word out of what I am sharing with you today. The Palestinians are living under a military occupation. It is an occupation that has now lasted 50 years – the longest military occupation in the modern era. What does occupation mean? Well, one thing it means is that in the West Bank, Palestinians are subject to military law. The Israeli military commander creates and administers the law that applies to Palestinians. There are some 1800 orders that have been issued determining what is allowed and not allowed. There is no due process, as we expect in Canada. People are arrested on suspicion. They can be held in custody on Administrative Detention for six months without charge or trial, and this can be renewed six months at a time indefinitely. If they are charged, trials are before a military court without the usual safeguards.

Do the same laws apply to everyone living in the West Bank? They do not. In violation of International law, including the Fourth Geneva Convention, Israel has moved over 600,000 of its own citizens into the West Bank and East Jerusalem. These Israeli settlers are subject to Israeli laws and have trials in civil courts with all the legal protections we enjoy in Canada. Currently the illegal settlers comprise 1/5th of the population living there. Imagine the outcry if 1/5th of the residents of Toronto were subject to different laws, had a different court system and enjoyed way more privileges and protections than the majority.

Different courts and penal laws is only one of many ways in which the Occupation unjustly mistreats Palestinians while favouring the interests of illegal Settlers.

We all need water to survive, and grossly discriminatory access to water is another hallmark of the Occupation.

On Good Friday this year, we stayed with a Christian Family in Jifna, Palestine, near Ramallah. They have a beautiful large home in which they operate a B&B. Their greatest challenge: They only receive water two days per week. When water flows, they fill the tanks on their roof. But it was clear that we needed to conserve water, when taking showers or using the toilet. And for the family, the shortage of water is an inescapable omnipresent challenge in their life.

Even more difficult is the plight of communities to which the Israeli authorities completely deny piped water. Al Hadidya in the Jordan Valley is one of the many villages affected. It is a herding community headed by Abu Sakr. In October 2016 a Spanish Non-Government Organization (‘NGO’) constructed a 13 km pipe to supply Al Hadidiya with water, but this pipe was destroyed by the Israeli authorities on January 10, 2017. So, the Spanish NGO laid the pipe again. And on February 20, 2017 the Israeli authorities came again and cut the pipe in numerous places, so the community is now again without water. By contrast, nearby illegal Israeli settlements get all the water they want.

What is the Result? –
• While Palestinians in the West Bank survive, on average, on 30% less than the daily minimum water amounts recommended by the World Health Organization (‘WHO’), illegal Israeli settlers have, on average, more than three times the minimum.
• Where Palestinians are denied piped water, they survive on less than 20% of the WHO recommended amounts.
• When there are seasonal water shortages, water supplies to Palestinians are cut even further, while settler water supplies do not suffer.

When hearing stories about the impact of the Occupation, North Americans often ask – but what about the Israeli side? Surely we must listen to both perspectives on what is happening.

The irony is that through our press we constantly hear the Israeli perspective. A recent film, “The Occupation of the American Mind” illustrates the official Israeli story and how it bombards us through our media. The film suggests that Israeli policy is a determined effort to portray all Palestinians as terrorists while ignoring the continual grabbing of Palestinian territory by the Israelis. Israel highlights any perceived threat – such as the rockets fired from Gaza. And North American press constantly offers us the Israeli perspective, emphasizing the right of Israel to protect itself without telling us that it is the 4th largest military power in the world, and the only country in the Middle East that possesses nuclear weapons.

Much of this is beyond our comprehension. Hard to wrap our minds around. However, it is not so hard to grasp the story of what the occupation is doing to Palestinian children. As a grandparent this is so distressing to me. On the one hand, the children are very much like our children:
• They go to school.
• When they have difficulty, they receive special help. (A picture is shown of a child in a refugee camp receiving speech therapy.)
• They play in school grounds…
• … and wherever they can find the space to play.
 • And they enjoy picnics. (A picture is shown of two boys on a community picnic, to which the team was invited.)

And yet there is a dark side. Recently we celebrated the 13th birthday of my grandson. In Palestine 13th birthdays create increased anxiety for families. Let me explain why as I tell you about ‘Azzun, a Palestinian community of 10,000 people, surrounded by illegal Israeli settlements.

Our team made biweekly visits to this community, walked the streets and met with a municipal official. We did this as a form of support for the community. Why did it need extra support? Because regularly in the middle of the night, Israeli soldiers invade homes in this community to arrest children, often as young as 13.

This is what we were told by the aunt of one such 14-year-old boy, Nadal, the morning he was arrested. The Aunt, Tissan, is the English teacher in the ‘Azzun school and lives with Nadal and his family.

The soldiers arrived at about 1 a.m. They banged on the door, threatening to break it down if not opened. Aunt Tissan, whose bedroom is closest to the door, opened the door. The soldiers entered the house and forced everyone, other than Nadal, into the living room. They then made their way, with an interpreter, to Nadal’s bedroom. Aunt Tissan protested that Nadal is only 14. The soldiers replied that they had an order from the court permitting them to take boys under 18. When asked to show the order, they produced a document in Hebrew which no one in the family could read. The soldiers questioned Nadal for about an hour. When Nadal’s father asked to see Nadal, the soldiers refused to permit it. The soldiers left the house at about 2:30 a.m. and took Nadal with them. His hands were tied, his legs shackled and his head covered with a hood. The soldiers would not say where they were taking Nadal. Agencies working with children and representing them in court informed us that in circumstances like Nadal’s, the questioning, and treatment amounting to torture, often continues until the child signs a confession written in Hebrew, a language the child does not understand. After signing the confession, the child will be taken before a military tribunal, which is where he will, for the first time, see his parents and perhaps a lawyer. If the child pleads ‘Not Guilty’ he will be held in jail until trial, perhaps a year later.

What offences are these children alleged to have committed? Almost invariably it is stone throwing, an offence that does not exist in most countries, and one for which the child could be sentenced to 10 or 20 years in prison, depending on whether the stone is alleged to have been thrown at a stationary object such as the Israeli Wall or a moving object.

One of our United Church partners, Defense of Children International – Palestine, focuses on responding to this illegal mistreatment of children. Growing out of Defense for Children is a campaign launched in Canada this summer: No Way to Treat A Child.

The choir is going to sing “Imagine” today. You will hear these words: “You may say I’m a dreamer. But I’m not the only one. I hope some day you’ll join us. And the world will live as one”.

Marianna: 

These words express our hope that this congregation will join in making such a powerful dream a reality.

George has been part of this church for more than 40 years. On the other hand, over the last 40 years, I have experienced many different congregations and their particular ways of being.

One story that George has told me about his life at Bloor Street speaks to my soul about what I believe is essential to our practice of being Christian disciples. Many years ago, Cliff Elliott preached a sermon that so moved Bloor Streeters that an Amnesty International group was formed. Numerous members of this congregation became active in writing letters in support of people around the world whose human rights were violated. Cliff’s interpretation of God’s call was so clear and powerful that a group of people was moved to action.

And, as I tell you that story, I remember a colleague I knew when I was a relatively new minister. She was trying to discern whether she should leave the parish she was serving. No, she concluded, I see lives being changed so I believe God wants me to carry on here. Those two stories illustrate the essence of what I believe it means to be followers of Jesus – lives are changed, action is taken.

And George illustrates just that – having heard stories of what was happening in Palestine, he visited twice to see for himself. Out of those experiences he was led to volunteer – to go to serve. And now he is telling all of us the stories of what he witnessed. My prayer is that George’s witness, through his many years as part of this congregation; through his service as an ecumenical accompanier; and through the message that he shares today, will move specific people so that attitudes and lives will change.

Now, I expect that during its long history, Bloor Street has offered altar calls. Here’s ours – altar call, dream – ask. Together let’s become involved in the No Way to Treat a Child Campaign. Please take a card, go on the website, watch the video, appropriately called “Detaining Dreams”, sign the petition, give a card to a friend.

The campaign is only a beginning to educate more Canadians to the reality of what occupation means and how we can help the transformation to justice.

We want to move on to a three-week course focusing on colonialism and its effects in Canada and in Palestine. There are so many parallels. In the three weeks people will learn concrete ways in which we can work for change for children in particular – indigenous Canadian children and Palestinian children.

What we are asking today is for two people who will offer leadership to a group here at Bloor Street. We are asking for the same thing from the other five churches that George spoke at in this area. Leaders will have all the information they need to facilitate such a group.

I am convinced that the dream for a new world needs to be a shared dream – George may be a voice in the wilderness telling these stories but change won’t come about if he is the only dreamer within this congregation. Working together we can make a difference for the children of Palestine – boys like this. Please pray about this and talk to us about how you can contribute to this project in the near future.

George: 

This is where we intended to end today but events of the week overtook us. The recognition of Jerusalem as the capital of Israel by the American President has not furthered efforts to create peace between the two peoples.

We turn back to our reading of Isaiah’s words, from 2500 years ago, exulting in the return of the exiles to Jerusalem. “Comfort, O comfort my people, speak tenderly to Jerusalem”. Yet how can those words speak to a Jerusalem in which two peoples dwell if one of those people is to dominate the other? Isaiah offers two rather contradictory visions of the anticipated coming of God. “The Lord God comes with might and his arm rules for him” followed by “he will feed his flock like a shepherd, gather the lambs in his arms and gently lead them”.

What we are currently seeing in Jerusalem, and in the occupied West Bank is totally skewed to the image of might and military power. Perhaps as we yearn for peace in God’s holy land and the city of Jerusalem we might turn to the words of Psalm 133 which declare how wonderful it is, how pleasant for God’s people to live together in harmony. It is in that situation that the Lord has promised his blessing – life that never ends. Peace will only come from the struggle which will bring these two peoples to live together in justice and right relationships. Amen.

No comments:

Post a Comment